Tampilkan postingan dengan label article. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label article. Tampilkan semua postingan

Selasa, 30 Agustus 2011

Dark Fantasy: sub-genre or marketing ploy?

In recent years a new sub-genre has appeared in UK bookshops. Always located close to the Science Fiction & Fantasy shelves, the proudly labelled "Dark Fantasy" section contains a somewhat strange mix of books, mostly written by women.

But what IS Dark Fantasy? Is it a bona fide sub-genre? Or is it a marketing term, used to cover the range of paranormal romance/urban fiction/young adult titles that have proliferated since the success of Twilight, aimed at the post-Harry Potter generation of female readers?

Wikipedia gives a definition of sorts, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_fantasy] but starts by stating
"A strict definition for dark fantasy is difficult to pin down."
The entry goes on to say that
"The term itself may refer collectively to tales that are either horror-based or fantasy-based."
but what DOES seem clear is that there is a supernatural element, be it monsters, magic or a combination of both. Classic books such as Dracula by Bram Stoker or Grimm's Fairy Tales fall into this definition as they straddle the divide between Horror and Fantasy. They contain elements of both and have sinister undertones, as do the works of Edgar Allan Poe and H.P.Lovecraft. By the same definition, Stephen King - particularly his early novels, like Carrie and Salem's Lot - could be classified as Dark Fantasy; so too many books by Neil Gaiman, Angela Carter, Clive Barker, Tanith Lee or Anne Rice. Yet these authors are not to be found on the Dark Fantasy shelves.

So what do the booksellers and publishers classify as Dark Fantasy? Well... from recent browsing in my local Waterstones [one of the last remaining UK chain of bookshops] it seems to be a combination of Paranormal Romance, Urban Fantasy, light Horror and Young Adult books - mostly written by women and largely aimed at women too. I sometimes wonder if this section has been created in the light of the Twilight phenomena, a marketing ploy to capture the (mainly) teenage readership of the popular Stephenie Meyer series.

The feisty, 'kick-ass' female protagonist protecting the world from the 'evil' supernatural beings is a popular theme. There are a number of long-running series that fit in this category - the Sookie Stackhouse books by Charlaine Harris, the Anita Blake novels by Laurell K. Hamilton or the Women of the Underworld series by Kelley Armstrong for example. Another series that is similar is Jim Butcher's Dresden Files, however, the protagonist here is a male wizard and you will find these books shelved in the general Science Fiction & Fantasy section, not under the heading of Dark Fantasy!

A high proportion of Paranormal Romance books can be found in the Dark Fantasy section. Sherrilyn Kenyon's Darkhunter series, J.R. Ward's Black Dagger Brotherhood novels and Christine Feehan's Carpathian series are some of the more well known examples, all involving some form of the vampire mythology. But it isn't all 'sexy vampires'. P.C. Cast's Goddess Summoning series draws from Celtic and Greek mythologies. Atlantis is the basis for the Lords of the Underworld series by Gena Showalter. But in all of these series romance is a central theme, with the the mythology and worldbuilding providing context. However, it is fair to say that the background and history of the central characters, whether they be ancient Greeks converted to Dark Hunters by Artemis or Atlantean warriors, is worthy of any speculative fiction novel. It is the emphasis on romance that places these books firmly in the marketing section 'Dark Fantasy' thus keeping them well away from the sword and sandals aficionados and the space opera fanboys!

So, in conclusion, it seems clear that what is now labelled 'Dark Fiction' in UK bookshops today is a marketing construct, catering for the current fashion for vampires (mainly of the non-sparkly type, thankfully!), werewolves, shape-shifters etc. with a loosely romantic plotline. The publishers and booksellers are keen to feed the appetites of the older teenage/early 20's women, now that the Twilight series is complete. Five years ago this section didn't exist, now it commands 4 or 6 columns of shelves in my local shop, albeit tucked away around the corner from the 'real' Fantasy and Science Fiction. Dark Fantasy is quickly becoming speculative fiction's 'dirty little secret' and is dismissed (or completely ignored) by many  genre commentators. Yet there are some very good writers tucked away there. One thing I would suggest, however... if Gail Martin, Poppy Z Bryte, Nancy Collins or Tanith Lee were starting out today, would their books be classified as Dark Fantasy?

Sabtu, 11 Juni 2011

What Makes Good SF

An interesting article on what makes "good science fiction" is being featured on Kirkus Reviews. Couple of interesting points being made over there. Worth checking out and maybe even commenting on.


Just because I love reading science fiction stories doesn't mean that I love every science fiction story I read. Some stories simply work better than others. Why? The reasons are largely a matter of personal taste and opinion, sure, but that doesn't mean one can't at least begin to qualify said criteria.

What I came up with are the basic qualities of "good" science fiction literature...


Click here for the full article.

Rabu, 16 Februari 2011

Interesting Article on the State of Fantasy

I am sure other blogs have picked up on this as well, but over at Big Hollywood there is a post regarding the current state of the fantasy genre and how it has drastically moved from its roots of Tolkien and Howard. A same quote:

The mere trappings of the genre do nothing for me when wedded to the now-ubiquitous interminable soap-opera plots (a conservative friend of mine once accurately derided “fat fantasy” cycles such as Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time as “Lord of the Rings 90210”). Nor do they impress me in the least when placed into the hands of writers clearly bored with the classic mythic undertones of the genre, and who try to shake things up with what can best be described as postmodern blasphemies against our mythic heritage.

I personally feel that the author of the article, Leo Grin, is a tad out of touch with society and the current evolution of fantasy. He also seems to have misread his two beloved authors.

Also, an average Joe (Abercrombie) has decided to reply to the above author's claims and criticisms.

So did Adam Whitehead, a great blogger and reply.

Sabtu, 11 September 2010

The Truth About Young Adult Fiction

The Truth About Young Adult Fiction



It has always amazed me when adults dismiss a book as YA.  By dismissing a book and not bothering to give it the time of day because it is marketed toward the 12-14 age group is like only eating two of the major food groups.  There are a lot of gems out there.  Not to mention, it's only marketed to young readers.  Just because the publisher decides to put a book in the Young Adult track does not mean that the author wrote with teens in mind.

In the nineteenth century there was no classification of Young Adult, but many novels were written that were deemed acceptable for both young and old readers alike.  Some of these may even surprise you.  Charles Dickens' Oliver Twist and Great Expectations were common reading material for young readers, as well as Little Women, The Jungle Book, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Count of Monte Cristo.

The marketing classification of Young Adult did not emerge until after World War II in the late 1940s and the early 1950s, depending on where you live.  In this era J.D. Salinger presented the world with Catcher in the Rye, William Golding wrote Lord of the Flies, and Robert A. Heinlein published Tunnel in the Sky and Citizen of the Galaxy.   In 1957 the Young Adult Library Services Association, a division of the American Library Association, was founded in order to "advocate, promote and strengthen library service to [young readers]. . . and to support those who provide library service".

A little later, in 1960, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee was published.  A Wrinkle in Time by Madeline L'Engle was published shortly after in 1962.  In 1963, the Canadian author Farley Mowat published Never Cry Wolf  which is still standard reading in grade nine classes around his native country - alongside the books I already mentioned by Salinger and Golding.  Oh, and do not forget George Orwell's dystopian satire, Animal Farm, and William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet.

In the 1970s, Stephen King writes Carrie, Judy Blume tackles menstruation in a different way with Are You There God?  It's Me, Margaret and V.C. Andrews tells her sordid tale of incest and abuse in Flowers in the Attic.

In current YA there is a trend to move towards themes such as sexuality, pregnancy, teen mother/fatherhood, rape, abuse, suicide, drugs, and alcohol.  And I'm just naming a few.

So, what am I saying here?  Just as you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, you shouldn't judge it by its marketing classification.  Young Adult fiction is full of well written, provocative reads.

- Victoria

Minggu, 15 Agustus 2010

How Do You Judge a Book?

When approaching a book, what are your expectations?  What do you look for?  Does the cover influence you?  The title? What about the novel has to make you say "Yes!  That's what I'm looking for!"?

Here at Speculative Book Review, we look at many things.  While you see our major three criteria (Characterization, Plot and Style), there are many other factors that go along with it.  When looking at characterization, for instance, we're looking to see if the qualities a character has are realistic, consistent, well thought out, etc.  Of course, since the five of us at SBR are different people with different tastes, we all consider and weigh these sorts of things differently, even though we try to remain as objective and consistent as we can be.

When I'm looking for a new book to read, a book that I'm reading for myself, and do not have to worry about objectivity for the blog, I'm looking for a few things. 

First, and foremost, I want efficient, yet beautiful prose.  I want there to be tonnes of imagery, but with a minimum amount of words used for it.  I do not want pages of description, but I want to know exactly what something looks like.  This style of writing is hard to obtain, and I know that this shrinks the pool a bit, but it's the style I enjoy the most.  It's usually full of action oriented sentences, but can contain a dream-like quality to it.  Examples of authors who are quite good at this sort of thing would be Guy Gavriel Kay, Ursula K. Le Guin, Tanith Lee, and Sheri S. Tepper.

After style, I look for plot.  I prefer adventure stories.  Though, I do not require all of my adventure stories to include Indiana Jones and Tarzan-like antics and qualities in them.  All I require is a character to go out on a limb and actively do things and go places.  They do not have to go far, even if they only go a day's hike away, or across to the other side of the city, I'm fine.  But I do prefer the withdrawal and return  story patterns.  I enjoy it when a character has to leave their society (whether it be their family, their village, their realm) in order to figure something out, let it be something that saves everyone, or just saves themselves.  When it comes to the return part of the pattern, it does not have to be a literal return.  They do not have to go back to their parent's home, or their village or their realm, but they do return to so-called 'normal' life, as in, a life outside of this singular adventure.  They might go on more adventures later, but this particular one finishes.  This pattern can be repeated in a million different ways, so it never bores me.  It's how the author fleshes it out; fills in the details that interest me.

Personally, characterization is not big on my list.  If there's a strong style and a strong plot (strong as in, based on my wants/desires), then there should be strong characterization as well.  To me, characterization falls under the style category.  If you have weak characters, then you've failed in style as well.

Lastly, I really enjoy novels that showcase human frailties and faults.  Science fiction tends to do a better job at this than fantasy (or at least, there's more authors using science fiction to depict this).  Call me a cynic, but I just don't think humans are all we say we are.  We are not at the centre of the universe.  And honestly, while we're capable of wonderful things, we're also capable of acts that are just as terrible.  Look at what we're doing to our planet, for instance.  Look at what we do to each other.  I enjoy books that examine these sentiments in interesting and uncommon ways.  Authors like Arthur C. Clarke, Margaret Atwood, and some of the others I've mentioned before are great at this sort of story.

On to covers. . .  Do I let them influence me?  Sometimes, yeah, I do.  The cover is not going to be the final factor in whether I buy a book or not, but it does help me pick a book up in the first place.  Sometimes I just like going to a book store for a few hours and look at what they have.  More often than not, I do this when I'm looking for an author I have never read before.  If there's a book with a nice looking cover, I'm more inclined to pick it up, read the back blurb, and then if that interests me, I'll pick a random chunk of dialogue and see if it passes my dialogue test.  (This test includes looking for realism and quick little non-dialogue responses between lines of dialogue.  As in, whether or not someone scrunches their nose, or scratches their eyebrow, or sits down, or stands up or. . . you get the picture.)

For those books which are unfortunate to have what I deem to be 'bad' covers (I don't like my hero standing heroically with a weapon and staring into nothing.  In fact, I rather there not be people at all on a cover, unless it's a classic painting), I use their titles to influence me.  If the title is something along the lines of The Gleaming Sword or The Opal Stone (The Opal Stone  is actually a story I wrote when I was twelve.  That bit of information might put some perspective in there for you), I'm probably not going to pick it up.  The only way I would do this is if it came highly recommended to me by persons I trust. Please note the plural there.  Only one testimony is not enough in this case for me.  Why?  Well, I have a prejudice.  I'll admit it.  I'm prejudiced against books that have titles like The Gleaming Sword.  I am bigoted in the fact that I think they'll be silly and created for one of the lower common denominators, or at least twelve year olds, who're allowed to read such things, since they're young and don't know any better.  I am egotistical in that I think I'm intelligent, I am proud of my intelligence, and I want books which will challenge my intelligence.  I want to learn.  So there.  I've admitted it.

But enough about me.  What about you?

- Victoria