Tampilkan postingan dengan label graphic novel. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label graphic novel. Tampilkan semua postingan

Senin, 26 Desember 2011

REVIEW: Green Lantern: Blackest Night By Geoff Johns and Doug Mahnke

Green Lantern: Blackest Night By Geoff Johns and Doug Mahnke
Publishing information: Hardback; 272 Pages
Publisher: DC Comics; 13 July 2010
ISBN 10: 9781401227869
ISBN 13: 978-1401227869
Series
Copy: Out of pocket
Reviewer: Tyson

Synopsis: "Comics hottest writer Geoff Johns (GREEN LANTERN: SINESTRO CORPS WAR, THE FLASH, ACTION COMICS, JSA) and superstar artist Doug Mahnke (JLA, BATMAN, SUPERMAN) raise the dead in this must-read tie-in to the most anticipated comics event of the year, BLACKEST NIGHT. This hardcover collection starring Hal Jordan expands on the War of the Light as the evil Black Lanterns descend on all of the Corps throughout the universe, explains villain Black Hand's connection to death and the Black Lantern corps and features key plot points that are essential to enjoying the storyline to it's fullest.

For those of you that don't know there is not just the Green Lantern Corps., there are eight other colored rings. One of them happens to be Black, which gains its power through death. The Black Lantern Corps. wants to kill every living thing in the universe. It is up to the Green Lanterns and the other colored Corps. to remove the threat the Black Lanterns bring to the universe. Following on the heels of DC's Final Crisis series the Black Lanterns have drafted nearly every dead character in the DC Universe: Martian Manhunter, Batman, and a host of others.

The problem with Blackest Night is that as each issue comes to a close it feels as if a panel or two is missing to bridge the story together for the next chapter. While not difficult to piece things together it does interrupt the story a little bit. However, that said the story is interesting and anyone who loves Hal Jordan will enjoy this installment. There are only a few key players and I would have liked to have seen some of the other Earth Lanterns but Hal is a favorite for most GL fans so he takes stage front and center. Jon Stewart does play a part but Kyle and Guy are not seen which is disappointing. The ending is also not that satisfactory and there are a few plot holes, but with comic books you know that those holes are intentional and will come up in later issues.

The artwork is fantastic and with all the different colored rings in the story there are a lot of colors used in nearly every panel. While not my favorite Green Lantern story arc. Blackest Night is a major turning point in the mythos that is Green Lantern and the DC Universe. Any fan of Green Lantern needs to know about the events that took place and this is one of the easiest ways to read about it. With a sequel to the movie Green Lantern on its way you never know if some of the plot points to this arc may show up in future installments of the movie series. Recommended.

Plot 7/10
Characters 9/10
Style 7/10
Artwork 10/10

Overall 7/10

Senin, 28 November 2011

REVIEW: Superman/Batman: Public Enemies (Vol. 1) by Jeph Loeb and Ed McGuinness

Superman/Batman: Public Enemies by Jeph Loeb and Ed McGuinness
Publishing information: Paperback; 160 pages
Publisher: DC Comics; 1 April 2005
ISBN 10: 1401202209
ISBN 13: 978-1401202200
Series/ story arc
Copy: Out of Pocket
Reviewer: Tyson

Synopsis: "In Public Enemies, a huge remnant of Superman's home planet, Krypton, menaces Earth. Lex Luthor, U.S. president in current Superman stories, accuses the Man of Steel of complicity in the threat and commissions a squadron of superheroes to bring him in."

I am a fan of Jeph Loeb's work, he tends to write a compelling story for the few graphic novels that have featured his writing. In this case we have to iconic superheroes, Superman and Batman. They both have the same goal to bring the guilty to justice. Superman the boy scout and Batman the ruthless detective team up when the President of the United States, Lex Luthor, accuses Superman of being the vanguard from Krypton who are planning to attack and enslave the Earth.

The only issue I really had with the concept was that Superman was a fairly well established hero at this time and why he would now change his stripes made very little sense to me but again it is a comic book so, some suspension of disbelief is required. On top of the impending invasion there is also a very large Kryptonian meteor heading on a collision course with Earth which is weakening Superman. With Luthor putting a price on Superman's head, Batman steps in to work along side the Man of Steel.

The best thing about the graphic novel is that through out story arc are the thoughts of both Batman and Superman and while their methods may be completely opposite there is an understanding between then and it shows how well they work together. Superman the most powerful being on the planet and Batman, the World's Greatest Detective create a fairly powerful team, even if their methods vary greatly.

Knowing that Superman is a tough adversary, Luthor puts together his own super powered bounty hunters which are charged with bringing in Superman and anyone else that is harboring or associate with him. The team plays to win and again we see how well Superman and Batman work together. There are some unexpected surprises along the storyline as well as a lot of cameos. It makes for a exciting read and as I said before a fun storyline.

Ed McGuinness' artwork is colorful and bold. It has his own style and flair while doing its best to show of the classical images we associate with Superheroes. Superman/Batman: Public Enemies (Vol.1) is a highly charged graphic novel with a lot to look forward to as you read it. It packs a lot of adventure in only a few pages. Recommended.

Plot 8
Characters 9
Style 8
Artwork 8.5

Overrall 8.5/10

Senin, 14 November 2011

REVIEW: Superman Birthright by Mark Waid

Superman: Birthright by Mark Waid
Publishing information: Graphic Novel paperback; 314 pages
Publisher: DC Comics; 1 October 2005
ISBN 10: 1401202527
SIBN 13: 978-1401202521
Standalone
Copy: Out of Pocket
Reviewer: Tyson

Synopsis: "Superman's origins have been imagined and reimagined over the years. Here is a new take on the character's roots. Superman: Birthright retells the early chapters of Superman's story, from escape as an infant from the doomed planet Krypton to arrival as reporter Clark Kent at the Daily Planet and his first public exploits. Writer Waid puts his own spin on the legend, rethinking nearly every aspect of the venerable character while remaining respectful of his established history. Waid wisely integrates ideas from the popular TV series smallville but doesn't slavishly follow its innovations; for instance, a young Lex Luthor befriends Clark in high school, but unlike in the series, his sinister nature is clear even then. Waid similarly tweaks the rest of the well-known cast, from Lois Lane and Clark's other Planet colleagues to Ma and Pa Kent. Ironically, though he updates the character, Waid evokes Superman's pre-World War II incarnation, whom his Depression-reared creators kept engaged in righting society's ills. Leinil Francis Yu's stylized artwork is expressively dynamic to the point of caricature, but this larger-than-life visual approach befits the retelling of a myth."

Superman has been re-invisioned many times, but coming of the tails of the successful television series Smallville DC must have wanted an updated version. There are a few changes. Befriending Lex Luthor during his time as a teenager is new; However, Lex is an evil genius even then. I did like some of the dynamic presented. It showed Clark as a helpful person even then, but he was rather naive as he still had not figured out that Kryptonite could weaken and possibly kill him. Even though Lex had figured it out within seconds. I know that as a teenager Clark is suppose to not know much about the world but he should also be a fairly good student with the ability to quickly think things through and act even quicker. Many of the other characters were also present and they all had slight re-imaginings but nothing really stood out. I was surprised that Waid did not take advantage of adding Chloe or Pete, but then again Lana Lang played a very small role and if I recall only had one or two panels dedicated to her. The overall story arc is the beginning of Clark's rise to become Superman and Lex Luthor's nemesis.

The artwork is impressive. It has a touch of the Superman of old, while also keeping it closer to the present. Overall Superman: Birthright is a great read and earns its spot on the shelf as a retelling of Superman's origins. Birthright does not shock the readers with anything drastic and plays well to those who are super fans. It updates without deviating too far from what we are use to. It would have been nice to see something new to add to the legend it decided to play it very straight laced. While not necessary to read to gain anything new or insightful about Superman or Lex Luthor it is a great story arc and features some nice artwork.

Plot 7/10
Characters 7/10
Style 7/10
Artwork 8/10

Overall 7/10

Senin, 07 November 2011

REVIEW: Orcs: Forged for War by Stan Nicholls & Joe Flood

Orcs, Forged for War by Stan Nicholls & Joe Flood
Publishing Information: Trade Paperback; 208 pages
Publisher: First Second Books (21 Oct 2011)
ISBN 10: 1596434554
ISBN 13: 978-1596434554
Copy: Sent by the publisher
Reviewer: Yagiz

"Orcs: Forged for War is the first graphic novel in Stan Nicholls’ beloved Orcs universe. The fantasy landscape in this world is brutal and unforgiving, and populated by a race of unlikely protagonists: the powerful and violent warriors, orcs.

Orcs: Forged for War is an original story—a new entry in this series, not an adaptation of old material. It follows a ruthless and deadly cohort of warrior orcs as they fight their way free of the dominion of an evil human enchantress. Sitting on an exhilarating peak with high fantasy on one side and the thrilling, gruesome battlefields of graphic novel classics like Frank Miller’s 300 on the other, Orcs presents the world of its ogre-like protagonists with technicolor violence and moments of unexpected sympathy."


I love comic books. I started to read them when I was a kid and, as far as I can remember, my first fantasy comic book was an issue of Conan. My uncle loved (still loves) Conan comics and he collected them. I can clearly remember feeling as excited as a pirate in a vast treasure room. I used to read them for hours.

Then when I moved to France for college, I met a different and much more developed comic book culture. Les Bandes Dessinées, or simply les BDs, are absolutely huge in France and in Belgium. During the following years, I had the pleasure to read the work of some great artists with various different styles. I still use amazon.fr to order my BDs.

So when I caught a glimpse of Stan Nicholls & Joe Flood's Orcs: Forged for War, I knew I had to read it. I also really liked its cover art. With its blood-red background and the lone orc warrior with a bloody longsword, it is a good indicator of what's inside.

The book's setting is Nicholls' Maras-Dantia where various races co-exist, but not so happily. It is evident that there's a lot of inter-racial tension and this not only between humans and the Elder Races but also among the Elder Races. Orcs are just one of those Elder Races and they make up for their lack of magical powers with their ferocity and skill on the battle field. They are a race full of surprises and contradictions as they are not painted all in black a la Tolkien (who didn't invent them, by the way).

The story revolves around a band of Orc warriors called Wolverines. The only non-Orc member of the group is a Dwarf who is one of the two sergents under the command of Captain Stryke. According to the story, Captain Stryke is given the responsibility of escorting a convoy under the orders of a Goblin wizard. Orcs and Goblins hate each other so you can guess the general mood of the mission. His hands being tied, Captain Strkye has no choice but to comply with the orders of his empress.

I like the story but it is fairly simple. I would have expected more suspense. I believe the reader is given obvious clues about the things that's going to happen. At first I wasn't in love with the style of Joe Flood however it grew on me as I read it. The book reads pretty fast. It is not one of those dialogue-heavy graphic novels. And be ready for some real action, fight, war, gore and burnt bodies. You've been warned. Orcs: Forged for War is definitely not for your young kids.

Also, don't forget to visit Orcs Sketchbook, The Making of the Graphic Novel, Orcs: Forged for War where you can get the freshest news and various sketches by Joe Flood.

I must confess, I hadn't read Nicholls' Orcs trilogies. However, despite some problems, I, not only enjoyed Orcs: Forged for War but I now have this itch about picking up Bodyguard of Lightning, the first book of his First Blood trilogy.

Plot: ............. 7
Characters: ... 8
Style: ............ 8

Overall: ....... 8/10

Rabu, 22 Desember 2010

REVIEW: Fables: Legends in Exile by Bill Willingham

Fables: Legends in Exile by Bill Willingham
Fables series, 01
Paperback: 128 pages
Publisher: Titan Books Ltd (25 April 2003)
ISBN-10: 1840236140
ISBN-13: 978-1840236149

From the back of the book:
Who killed Rose Red?
In Fabletown, where the fairy tale legends live alongside regular New Yorkers, the question is all anyone can talk about. But only the Big Bad Wolf can actually solve the case - and, along with Rose's sister Snow White, keep the Fabletown community from coming apart at the seams.


This is a graphic novel, and very different to what I had expected. As the title suggests, the familiar characters from traditional fairy stories have been exiled from their homeland to New York. Being the first book in the series, Legends in Exile gives us the back story of why they moved to New York but this is secondary to the murder mystery: who killed Rose Red?

Snow White is the Chief of Operations and deputy Mayor of Fabletown, a sharp, hard-nosed businesswoman with no time for sentiment. She is told of her sister's disappearance and possible murder by Bigby, the Big Bad Wolf and Head of Security. Suspects emerge, including Jack (of the beanstalk fame), Bluebeard who had a secret marriage deal with Rose Red and Prince Charming (because Snow White still loathes him despite their divorce). There is a bloody crime scene, twists and turns in the search for the killer, and a classic 'parlour' denouement.

But what makes Legends in Exile so fascinating is the characterisation. For example, Prince Charming is a classic womaniser, divorced from both Snow White and Cinderella, broke and making his living by selling off his titles and sponging off the women he seduces. Little Boy Blue is Snow White's PA, complete with a trumpet on his desk. King Cole is now the Mayor of Fabletown. I found this aspect both clever and amusing. Although the characters were familiar from nursery rhymes and fairy stories, adapting them to the modern world was well done, I thought.

There is a lot of humour in Legends in Exile, from sarcastic comments to visual jokes, all of it very tongue in cheek. However, like the original fairy tales it draws from, this has dark undertones. I liked the artwork, some of the larger scenes were very detailed and merited further examination to check out what was going on in the background. Being fairly new to the world of graphic novels, I was surprised at how enjoyable reading this was. Other than The Furry Freak Brothers, I hadn't read any comics since childhood, but I am glad I read Legends in Exile, and may even check out other volumes in the series.

Plot 6
Characters 7
Style 8

Overall 7/10